Which One Is Better for Anxiety: Fidget Spinner or Stress Ball?
Share
Introduction
Anxiety has a sneaky way of showing up when you least want it to—tight chest, restless thoughts, hands that just can’t stay still. And for a lot of people (myself included), finding small, simple ways to channel that energy can make a real difference. That’s where fidget tools come in.
Over the past few years, fidget spinners and stress balls have become two of the most popular anxiety-relief gadgets on the planet. You’ll find them everywhere—from classrooms and office desks to therapy rooms and glove compartments.
But which one actually helps more when anxiety hits—a fidget spinner or a stress ball? Let’s break it down.
Quick Overview: Fidget Spinner vs. Stress Ball
Fidget Spinner:
A fidget spinner is basically a small, ball-bearing device that spins between your fingers. It exploded in popularity around 2017, mostly as a “fun trend,” but people quickly noticed something deeper—it could calm nerves and quiet a racing mind. The spinning motion gives your hands something to do, your eyes something to follow, and your brain a rhythm to anchor itself to.
Stress Ball:
The stress ball has been around for decades, long before the TikTok generation made “fidgeting” cool. Usually made of foam, gel, or rubber, you squeeze it in your hand to release muscle tension. It’s low-tech, quiet, and almost always works when you just need something to grip during anxious moments.
Both tools promise relief—but they do it in different ways.
How Each One Helps with Anxiety
Fidget Spinner
Spinners work by giving your hands a repetitive, rhythmic motion to focus on. That sensory input can help redirect anxious energy. For some people, the spinning sound or the visual movement can even feel hypnotic in a good way—it helps the brain downshift from overdrive.
I’ve used one during late-night work sessions or before big meetings when my nerves were fried. It helps me focus, not zone out. That little whirl of movement becomes a background hum that quiets the noise in my head.
But fidget spinners do have drawbacks. They’re not exactly subtle—you’ll get a few looks in a quiet meeting. They can also be distracting or overstimulating if you’re already edgy.
Stress Ball
A stress ball is all about release. Every squeeze activates the muscles in your hand and forearm, burning off some of that anxious tension that builds up physically. That simple action—tighten, hold, release—mimics the rhythm of deep breathing without you even realizing it.
It’s also discreet. You can use it at your desk, on the train, or while waiting in line. I’ve carried one in my bag for years. It’s not flashy, it doesn’t spin, but it does its job quietly and effectively.
Downsides? Stress balls can wear out or lose their firmness over time. And for people who crave constant motion or visual feedback, they might feel too dull.
The Science (or Lack of It)
Let’s be honest—there isn’t a mountain of hard science proving that fidget toys cure anxiety. But there’s growing support from mental health professionals and anecdotal evidence from people who use them every day.
Studies suggest that fidgeting can improve concentration and help regulate nervous energy. Therapists often recommend tools like these for people with ADHD or generalized anxiety.
What it really comes down to is individual response. Some people swear by the soothing motion of a spinner. Others find comfort in the physical grounding of a stress ball. Both have merit.
For a deeper dive into the psychology behind these gadgets, check out The Ultimate Guide to Stress Reliever Toys: Why They Actually Work.
Which One Works Best for You?
Here’s a quick cheat sheet:
Go for a Fidget Spinner if you:
- Get bored easily and need visual or kinetic stimulation.
- Like to keep your hands moving while thinking or studying.
- Find spinning or repetitive motion calming.
Go for a Stress Ball if you:
- Want something simple, silent, and low-maintenance.
- Tend to hold tension in your body or hands.
- Need a grounding tool for quick, discreet anxiety relief.
Some people even combine both—spinning when they need movement, squeezing when they need calm. There’s no wrong answer, just what works for you in the moment.
Real-World Scenarios
- At Work: A stress ball wins here. It’s quiet, unobtrusive, and gives your hands something to do without drawing attention. Perfect for tense calls or long meetings.
- At Home or While Studying: The fidget spinner might be better. It can help you focus, think, and process without feeling trapped in your thoughts.
- On the Go: Either works. I keep a stress ball in my bag, and a spinner on my desk. Different tools for different moods.
You can explore a full range of both options at ReliefToys.com — they’ve got curated collections of fidget toys and stress relief toys worth checking out.
Conclusion
So, which one is better for anxiety—the fidget spinner or the stress ball? The truth is, it depends. Both work in their own way, both have fans, and both can genuinely help when your mind starts to spiral.
If you’re not sure which to choose, experiment. Try one for a week, then switch. See which one your hands reach for when anxiety starts to creep in. Because that’s the real test—not what studies say, not what trends say—but what feels right for you.
At the end of the day, the goal isn’t to “beat” anxiety with a gadget—it’s to manage it in a way that feels human, simple, and doable.
And if you’re curious about other tools that can help calm your nerves naturally, take a look at the Calm in Motion Blog for more real-world insight and tips.
FAQ
Can kids use fidget spinners or stress balls for anxiety?
Yes—both are safe and widely used for kids who struggle with focus or anxiety. Just make sure the spinner is sturdy and age-appropriate.
Do fidget toys really work?
They’re not magic, but they can absolutely help manage symptoms by giving your body a safe outlet for restlessness and tension.
Are there alternatives?
Definitely. Fidget cubes, therapy putty, and sensory rings are great options too. You can find many of them at ReliefToys.com.